Download Article
To Suggested Citation
Suggested Citation
Möhlmann, M., & Teubner, T. (2020). Navigating by the Stars: Current Challenges for Ensuring Trust in the Sharing Economy. NIM Marketing Intelligence Review, 12(2), 22-27. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/nimmir-2020-0013

Register for our Newsletter

NIM Marketing Intelligence Review – The Reputation Economy

Navigating by the Stars: Current Challenges for Ensuring Trust in the Sharing Economy

Authors

Download Article

Mareike Moehlmann and Timm Teubner 

Today, virtually all e-commerce and sharing-economy platforms rely on star ratings or similar systems to build trust between anonymous buyers and sellers. However, star ratings can be quite tricky as a navigation aid. Platforms and users face several challenges in making sure that reputation systems remain credible. Skewed ratings and low rating variance, however, make it difficult for users to differentiate good from bad products and services. To tackle the issue of retaliation, most platforms use so-called simultaneous review schemes, only publishing ratings once both parties have committed. Furthermore, platforms may offer individuals the opportunity to leave text reviews as a complement to numeric ratings. A growing number of platforms also use complex technical systems and algorithms to automatically identify, mark or delete fake news. To maintain legitimacy, platform operators need to design reputation systems with minimal negative side effects and make crucial decisions about the level of control they seek to enact. 

Authors

Share Publication
Suggested Citation
Möhlmann, M., & Teubner, T. (2020). Navigating by the Stars: Current Challenges for Ensuring Trust in the Sharing Economy. NIM Marketing Intelligence Review, 12(2), 22-27. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/nimmir-2020-0013


Other articles of the MIR issue “The Reputation Economy”

Here you can find more exciting articles of this issue.

To the entire issue

[Translate to English:]

Playing the Trust Game Successfully in the Reputation Economy

Hunting for “stars”, the icons of the reputation economy, is a prerequisite for survival in e-commerce in general and on sharing platforms …

Go to article
[Translate to English:]

Reaching for the Stars: The Role and Value of Digital Reputation

In the old economy, reputation was considered an important but somewhat underestimated intangible asset. In the digital economy, the …

Go to article
[Translate to English:]

Detecting and Mitigating Discrimination in Online Platforms: Lessons from Airbnb, Uber, and Others

Research has documented racial or ethnic discrimination in online marketplaces, from labor markets to credit applications to housing.

Go to article
[Translate to English:]

Tit for Tat? The Difficulty of Designing Two-Sided Reputation Systems

In a two-sided reputation system, it is in the interest of both buyers and sellers to be a good transaction partner. What sounds wonderful …

Go to article

Tales from the Land of Consumer Reviews: Taking a Closer Look at Lurkers and Writers

While most consumers routinely read online reviews to inform their purchase decisions, the number of consumers who actively post reviews …

Go to article
[Translate to English:]

It’s the Story, Stupid: The Consumer Reviews Most Likely to Influence Purchasing Decisions

Helpful reviews are like good movies or a good novel: if you’re hooked right away, you stay and remember. No matter how short, a review …

Go to article
[Translate to English:]

Hosting Bags Instead of People

For many travelers, the problem is familiar: You check out from Airbnb and your flight is not till later. So you have time to still enjoy …

Go to article
[Translate to English:]

Thrilled or Upset: What Drives People to Share and Review Product Experiences?

What drives people’s decisions to share product and service experiences? Several studies show that a sender’s emotional arousal is a …

Go to article

Latest issues

2024-10

Platform Business

Go to issue

2024-04

Generative AI - Reshaping the Marketing Landscape

Go to issue

2023-11

Virtual Consumer Experiences - The Future of Shopping in the Metaverse

Go to issue
Scroll to top